95SN0141 & 95SN0142
-
November 15, 1994 ere
December 14, 1994 BS
REQUEST ANALYSIS
AND
RECOMMENDATION
95SN0141 & 95SN0142
Chesterfield County Board of Supervisors
Countywide
REOUEST: Amendment to non-residential zoning cases approved with the cash proffer for
fire protection services, to eliminate this proffered condition. Specifically, on
May 25, 1994, the Board of Supervisors decided to eliminate the cash proffer for
fire protection services for all existing, approved non-residential zoning cases for
which the proffer has been accepted, and further decided to not seek this proffer
for all future non-residential cases.
PLANNING COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION
RECOMMEND APPROVAL.
STAFF RECOMMENDATION
Recommend approval for the following reasons:
A. The cost to administer the commercial fire protection cash proffer program
exceeds the benefits gained.
B. Elimination of the fire protection cash proffer will not adversely impact the ability
to provide adequate fire protection to future development.
GENERAL INFORMATION
Location:
See attached
Existing Zoning:
Non-residential
Existing Land Use:
Non-residential or vacant
PUBLIC FACILITIES
Zoning History and Conclusions:
At the May 25, 1994, annual work session, the Board of Supervisors reviewed the new
cash proffer amounts for Fiscal Year 1995, and staff reviewed the status of the
commercial fire protection cash proffer program. The review indicated that since 1990,
of the 59 zoning cases approved with the fire protection cash proffer, only seven (7) had
paid the proffer (a total of $7,970 has been collected) and four (4) had elected to install
extra suppression systems. It was noted that the cost to administer the commercial fire
protection cash proffer program exceeded the benefits gained. Staff requested that the
commercial fire protection cash proffer be eliminated from the proffer policy for all
future zoning cases. The Board approved this request and further directed that all zoning
cases previously approved with the commercial fire proffer be amended to eliminate this
condition. 'Therefore, staff recommends approval of this request.
CASE HISTORY
Planning Commission Meeting (11/15/94):
There was no opposition present. Mr. Miller declared a conflict of interest on Tax Map
52-10 (1) Part of Parcel 5.
On motion of Mr. Gulley, seconded by Mr. Cunningham, the Commission recommended
approval of this request excluding Tax Map 52-10 (1) Part of Parcel 5.
AYES: Unanimous.
On motion of Mr. Gulley, seconded by Mr. Easter, the Commission recommended
approval of this request for Tax Map 52-10 (1) Part of Parcel 5.
A YES: Messrs. Marsh, Cunningham, Easter and Gulley.
ABSENT: Mr. Miller.
The Board of Supervisors on Wednesday, December 14, 1994, beginning at 7:00 p. m., will
take under consideration this request.
2 95SN0141&95SN0142/WP/DEC14K
-
- -
COMMERCIAL FIRE PRI :CTION PROFFER CASES
DATE
CASE # APPROVED
MAP
PARCEL
NUMBER
APPLICANT
American Tabacco
91SN0225 91-09-25 119-14-01-00-000-003
Adams, RobertlBetty
93SN0179 93-07-28 081-08-02-00-000-008
Beasley, Gordon
93SNOI99 93-07-28 052-07-01-00-000-003
Beck, Arnold
89SN0429 90-03- 28 066-01-01-00-000-007
B&K(Ironbridge Learning Ctr)
93SNOI58 93-02-24 079-04-01-00-000-025
Carter, Elvira
9OSN0152 90-05-23 049-07-01-00-000-010
Central Virginia Bank
93SNOI94 93-07-28 037-13-01-00-000-005
Cooke, Mark
9OSN0189 90-06-27 016-11-01-00-000-015 PT
Costner, Bruce
9OSNOI04 90-03-28 079-10-01-00-000-006
079-10-01-00-000-007
Dean/Hinson
93SN0231 93-08-25 115-06-01-00-000-051
115-10-01-00-000-046
Dodds Leasing
93SNOI34 92-11-17 116-06-01-00-000-102 PT
Earnest, Terry
93SN0228 93-08-25 015-11-01-00-000-043
Exxon Corporation 94SNOl23 93-11-23 068-05-01-00-000-003
068-05-01-00-000-004
068-05-01-00-000-005
Finkler, Constance 94SNOI08 93-10-27 115-04-01-00-000-028
Fraternal Order
91SROI46 91-06-26 109-12-01-00-000-001
COMMERCIAL FIRE PROTECTION PROFFER CASES·
DATE
CASE # APPROVED
MAP
PARCEL
NUMBER
APPLICANT
Hampton Inn
92SNOI03 92-02-26 116-08-01-00-000-038
Hubbard, James
9OSNOI85 90-10-24 050-05-01-00-000-001
Hubbard, James
92SN0130 92-05-27 075-05-01-00-000-006
Hubbard, James
93SN0255 93-10-27 048-01-01-00-000-032
Huguenot- Robious
9OSN0244 90-09- 26 009-13- 01-00-000-034
Myers, Henry
91SN0200 91-08-28 095-12-01-00-000-044 PT
095-12-01-00-000-049
Peeba Associates
9OSN0205 91-08-28 135-04-02-00-000-052
Ranson, R.F ./Post Office
91SN0251 91-11-27 073-00-01-00-000-099
Ratcliffe, Phillip
91SN0254 91-11- 27 133-11-01-00-000-001
S & J Enterprises
92SN0208 92-10-28 040-02-01-00-000-013
Sarver, Bob/Brenda
91SN0270 91-12-11 028-11-01-00-000-015
Shoo smith Brothers
9OSN0304 91-01-23 114-14-01-00-000-014 PT
Sydney Realty
91SN0131 91-04-24 028-01-01-00-000-012
Taylor, James
91SN0287 91-12-11 015-16-01-00-000-018
Thorpe, Charles
93SNOI60 93-02-24 040-02-01-00-000-117
-
COMMERCIAL FIRE PROTECTION PROFFER CASES
DATE
CASE # APPROVED
MAP
PARCEL
NUMBER
APPLICANT
Daniels, Jim
91SN0247 92-03-25 115-10-01-00-000-002
115-10-01-00-000-003
Duval, William/Gene
92SN0167 92-09-23 015-16-01-00-000-003
015-16-01-00-000-010
015 -16-01-00-000-011
015-16-01-00-000-012
015-16-01-00-000-017
Enochs, James
91 SNO 178 91-12-11 118-09-02-00-000-053
118-09-02-00-000-054
118-09-02-00-000-057
Gray, Frederick
91SN0276 93-07-28 118-14-01-00-000-019
118-14-01-00-000-024
Horner, James
93SNOl80 93-06-23 049-13-01-00-000-013
049-14-01-00-000-022
Hubbard, James
9OSN0300 91-01-23 017-10-01-00-000-015 PT
017-15-01-00-000-003
Martin, Charles
91SN0232 91-10-23 009-09-01-00-000-009
Miller, Thomas
9OSN0306 91-04-24 066-09-01-00-000-043
066-09-01-00-000-029 PT
066-09-01-00-000-046
066-09-01-00-000-048
066-09-01-00-000-047
Payne, Thomas
91SN0244 91-10-23 097-06-01-00-000-067
097-06-01-00-000-068 PT
-
COMMERCIAL FIRE PR,-CTION PROFFER CASES
APPLICANT
UkropsSupermarkeU
Virginia State University CU
Wilton, Carlton (Service Merch)
Wood, Helen Taylor
Barney, Robert
Brown, Stephen/Belita
Carnes, W.S.
Church of Our Saviour
Conner, Robert
Consolidated Sales Co., Inc.
-
DATE
CASE # APPROVED
MAP
PARCEL
NUMBER
91SN0161 91-07-24 079-15-01-00-000-032
095-03-01-00-000-038
91SN0139 91-04-24 182-10-01-00-000-008
9OSNOl86 90-06-27 016-08-01-00-000-012
91SN0304 92-01-22 029-01-01-00-000-017
9OSN0118 90-06-27 015-10-01-00-000-016PT
015-10-01-00-000-021PT
92SNOI71 92-07-22 095-12-01-00-000-008
095-12-01-00-000-025
9OSN0289 90-12-12 052-10-01-00-000-005PT
93SN0213 93-09-22 049-13-01-00-000-006
049-14-01-00-000-001
049-14-01-00 -000-002
049-14-01-00-000-017
91SN0271 91-11-27 075-02-01-00-000-032PT
075-02-01-00 -000-0 11
075-02-01-00-000-013
075-02-01-00-000-028
94SNOll0 94-03-23 009-13-01-00-000-010 PT
016-04-01- 00-000-011
016- 08- 01- 00 -000-0 18
016-04-01-00-000-016
-
COMMERCIAL FIRE PR( ;CTION PROFFER CASES
MAP
PARCEL
NUMBER
DAlE
CASE # APPROVED
APPLICANT
l~.itter/Wood
91SN0305 92-02-26 019-13-01-00-000-031
029-01-01-00-000-022
029-01-01-00-000-023
:3heltering Arms Hospital
92SN0112 92-04-22 018-15-01-00-000-006
018-15-01-00-000-059
Shoo smith Brothers
91SN0269 91-12-11 136-00-01-00-000-011
Shoosmith, Nina
91SN0123 91-02-27 068-06-02-00-000-022
TPJ, Inc.
93 SNO 147 94-02-23 097-06-01-00-000-004
097-06-01-00-000-060
097 -10-01-00-000-013
097-10-01-00-000-001 PT
WaldroplHill
9OSN0288 90-12-12 075-02-01-00-000-004
075-02-01-00-000-029
075-02-01-00-000-030
YMCA
93SNOI08 92-09-23 040-01-01-00-000-020
040-01-01-00-000-021
HMK
91SN0249 92-02-26 011-05-01-00-000-010
011-09-01-00-000-002
011-13-01-00-000-015
011-13-01-00-000-016
011-13-01-00-000-021
011-13-01-00-000-028
011-13-03-0A-OOA-OOl
COMMERCIAL FIRE PROTECTION PROFFER CASES
APPLICANT
DATE
CASE # APPROVED
MAP
PARCEL
NUMBER
019-01-01-00-000-005
019-01-01-00-000-006
019-01-01-00-000-007
019-01-01-00-000-008
019-01-01-00-000-011
019-01-01-00-000-012
019-01-01-00-000-013
019-01-01-00-000-014
019-01-04-00-00A-001
019-01-04-00-00A -002
019-01-04-00-ooA -003
019-01-04-00-ooA-004
019-01-04-00-00A-005
019-01-04-00-00A-006
019-01-04-00-ooA-007
019-01-04-00-00A-008
019-01-04-00-00A-009
019-01-04-00-00A-OI0
019-01-04-00-00B-00l
019-01-04-00-00B-002
019-01-04-00-00B-003
019-01- O4-00-00B-004
019-01- 04-00-00B-005
019-01-04-00-ooB-006
019-01-04-00-00B-007
019-01-04-00-00B-008
019-01- O4-00-00B-008A
019-01-04-00-00C-OOlA
019-01-04-00-00C-OOl
019-01-04-00-00C-002
019-01-04-00-00C-002A
Hubbard, James
91SN0230 93-08-25 017-16-01-00-000-001
017 -16-01-00-000-002
017 -16-01-00-000-004
,-
-
COMMERCIAL FIRE PR( ~CTION PROFFER CASES
APPLICANT
DATE
CASE # APPROVED
MAP
PARCEL
NUMBER
017 -16-01-00-000-005
017 -16-01-00-000-024
018-13-01-00-000-003
018-13-01-00-000-014
018-13-01-00-000-015
018-13-01-00-000-016
018-13-01-00-000-042
018-13-01-00-000-043